Drawing on philosophy and anti-modernism, Germany’s Bonjour Tristesse deliver a grimly satisfying post-black metal banger with Disaster Triumphant.
Release date: November 20, 2026 | AOP Records | Facebook | Instagram | Bandcamp
When we are taught history and philosophy, we learn from a Western perspective. Both of these fields treat time and progress as linear trajectories, and the entirety of our current education system follows this approach. This may seem reasonable, like a series of logical causes and effects that may hiccup and overstep into tragedy, but naturally self-correct with more time, more reason, more rationality. The primary reason for this linear way of thinking stems from the much-lauded Enlightenment period, taught as if the Dark Ages were merely centuries of barbarism and ignorance until some noble and intelligent Europeans miraculously managed to think harder than anyone had since the early Greek philosophers (also suspiciously of the Western canon). Rationalism became the dominant mode of philosophy, the assertion that humans are born with some level of innate knowledge and therefore all truths can be understood through reasoning and deduction.
The common counter-argument is empiricism, which (perhaps problematically) supposes that we are born in tabula rasa, the blank slate, and therefore all knowledge and truths are derived from sensory experiences. Both rationalism and empiricism have been debated in philosophy since the Age of Enlightenment, but rationalism has been a powerful force in shaping culture. As we have witnessed and continue to witness, rationalism, when applied to politics and economics, can quickly begin to treat humans as a means to an end. Capitalism sees people as profit potential more than rational individuals, and the further down this line of reasoning we go the closer we approach fascism. Through ‘reason‘ we can find scapegoats, problems as groups of people who by this prioritization of deductive principles can quickly be reduced to subhuman. Thus, we can justify enslavement, colonization, genocide, and technologies and ‘progress‘ that wantonly leaves undesirables behind, bolstered by the myth of human supremacy.
This critique means that the aim of The Enlightenment as a means to liberate humanity has been a failure. Humanity, in many ways, is still largely subservient to the few who deem themselves masters, whether through political leadership and despotism, religious leadership, or by the bourgeoise manipulation of supply and artificial scarcity. Frankfurt School philosophers Max Horkheimer and Theodor Adorno sought to tackle this problem with their work Dialectics of Enlightenment (1947). Now, Nathanael, the German musician who writes and performs as Bonjour Tristesse, has taken inspiration from these ideas into his latest album, Disaster Triumphant. You don’t have to have a deep understanding of these heady conflicts to appreciate Bonjour Tristesse‘s depressive, atmospheric post-black metal. I certainly don’t, but I think that having a cursory understanding of the inspirations for Disaster Triumphant helps to illuminate what Nathanael has done here.
Bonjour Tristesse has been around since 2015 with a 5-year hiatus between 2018 and 2023. I became a fan when stumbling through Bandcamp looking for things labeled ‘RABM‘ (red and black metal, or anarcho-communist black metal) and finding 2018’s Your Ultimate Urban Nightmare. Other tags included DSBM (depressive suicidal black metal) and atmospheric black metal which are both more descriptive of a sound than a political stance, but it is always nice to know that your black metal at the very least claims to be antifascist. Anyway, I have been a fan for a while, now, and earlier this year went through Bonjour Tristesse‘s entire discography as my black metal fixation took hold once again.
Disaster Triumphant has all of the trappings of a trve cvlt black metal album: slowly unfolding minor keys, icy guitar tones, hellish shrieking vocals, and a recording style so lo-fi, you’d think the drums were recorded inside a pillow fort. Bonjour Tristesse isn’t seeking out new territory, but rather refining the sounds that define the project. Where Disaster Triumphant excels is in the slow chord progressions. There are no guitar solos or drastic instrumental changes, but rather a mostly-mid paced tromping series of subtly changing patterns that give each track emotional momentum, sort of like how the wash of guitars in shoegaze often creates introspective, ambient-like passages. This isn’t blackgaze, of course, but there is a similarity in the emotive climaxes. “The Heights Of Despair” illustrates this nicely, as the minor key chord progressions leave just enough hope and optimism to lend a little sliver of light into the bleakness.
This crafty compositional trick is repeated throughout the album, serving as a sonic representation of a dialectic. It seems to ask how can something be so melancholic and resolutely hopeful at the same time. On “At The Mountains Of Silence” Nathanael layers his vocals over themselves from line to line, letting the tail end of one lyric bleed into the beginning of the next, once again creating a paradox in that this gorgeous track can only be on record and impossible to recreate live. Lyrically, this song seems to be about an interpersonal relationship, but sonically it captures the mourning of a dying world, the layers of guitars enveloping the atmosphere like greenhouse gasses suffocating us with heat.
One could also argue that the lo-fi recording is representative of a rejection of modernity, something Nathanael has stated is a common theme of Bonjour Tristesse. Increasingly, I understand that sentiment. I do feel that technology and science have brought life sustaining advances to humanity, but as we gradually march towards our own decline, we must wonder at the cost, especially with big tech oligarchs advertising their disdain for humanity. “Tomb Of Hope” seems to ask this in its title as well as its music, again suffusing the doomed and abrasive tones with musical resolutions that carry as much beauty as they do misery, a mausoleum to humanity’s hopes and ambitions now squashed by the maniacal greed of a few suited brutes, driven spiritless by the reason and logic of their own invented markets.
Disaster Triumphant may seem like a contradictory title, but once something is called a disaster, that thing has already triumphed. As pessimistic as this music sounds and this outlook may be, this album feels like it was made for these times, gloomily soundtracking our collective doom. Bonjour Tristesse capture the ever droning feeling of unease that our progress is our undoing, whether it is persistently plodding along in the background or howling its despair to the light polluted moon. For those who seek the grim and morose as a complement to their own darker thoughts, Disaster Triumphant is the shadowy companion you’ve been looking for, an easy favorite. Reject modernity; embrace sorrow.




