Troye Sivan‘s feel-good fourth full-length takes a more subdued, Jack Antonoff-ed approach to production, and what do ya know! It works.

Release date: October 9, 2026 | Interscope Records | Facebook | Instagram | Website | YouTube

When it comes to big-name pop producers, Jack Antonoff of fun. and Bleachers fame has always been extremely hit-or-miss for me. I still hold the unfortunately controversial belief among critics that Lorde shouldn’t have worked with Antonoff for much of her second album Melodrama. Sanding off all her uniquely minimalist edges in favor of maximalist art pop bloat does not do the New Zealand pop star any good. By contrast, during the same year, Antonoff was at the producer’s helm for St. Vincent‘s fifth studio album MASSEDUCTION. Having listened to MASSEDUCTION recently, I strongly prefer MASSEDUCTION‘s restless energy and creativity over the background music pablum of Melodrama.

Over the years, Antonoff’s production became more and more ubiquitous in the pop world, thanks in large part to Taylor Swift being one of the first to boost his music producing career. That said, the number of songs–or in some cases, albums–he’s produced per artist varies wildly, including those for Australian dance-pop phenom Troye Sivan. Having worked with Antonoff before on only two songs, including “Strawberries & Cigarettes”, Sivan brings him back in for five cuts from his brand new LP, She’s the Best. Despite Antonoff contributing to less than half of the record, with other producers such as Oscar Görres and Styalz Fuego filling in the gaps, Sivan’s fourth album might just be his strongest body of work ever. It’s almost ten minutes longer than the previous LP Something to Give Each Other (2023), feeling much looser and more fleshed-out. As always, he reverts to his house-pop ways on tunes like “Party”, but unlike his 2023 album, the vibe is much less shrink-wrapped, plastic house, and more downplayed–much more alternative-flavored, too.

Whether he’s leaning into dreamy, guitar-focused soundscapes on “Le Boy”, “FF”, and the title track, or injecting us full of divinely feminine club energy on “Canada Dry” and “I Do This For You”, Sivan performs these twelve songs in a more subdued manner than any of his prior hits. However, neither his adventurous spoken word segments nor his hushed baritone delivery ever puts a damper on the album. The five tracks Antonoff helped produce–title track, “I Do This For You”, “Cowboy”, “Troye Meets World”, and “FF”–happen to be some of his strongest work as well as Sivan’s.

Lyrical vulgarities aside, there’s something genuinely soothing about the title track, an ode to a woman Sivan deeply admires for her quiet ferocity (‘She takes down an incel on the Internet / When she needs just a little unwind‘). No doubt this woman is a real baddie, but the song’s rolling trip hop beat and gentle flourishes of synth paint a beautiful picture. It only builds up from there, crescendoing voices and guitar noise emerging like the morning sunrise. Another song I keep wanting to return to is “Le Boy”, mainly because of its wall-of-sound climax and sturdy bass riff. Sure, the title is lame, as is “Troye Meets World” (which feels like an interlude, regardless), but after hearing the music, “Le Boy” is anything but that.

On the less introspective side of the spectrum, the album’s more Madonna-like moments don’t disappoint, either. “Party” technically is a Madonna song, really. It literally interpolates “Music” by the gay icon herself, and Sivan gestures towards that song’s hypnotic repetitiveness with a set of list-like lyrics himself. Meanwhile, the squelching acid arpeggiators of “Canada Dry” recall “Impressive Instant”, the song that follows “Music” on its namesake album, Music (2000). Both songs are excellent, but the one named after a brand of ginger ale is far superior, and if there’s one gripe I have about She’s the Best, it’s that the digital version available on streaming services fucks up the album’s flow really badly. For my money, it should be the title track leading into “Canada Dry” and then “Party”, the way that the gay gods intended. Naturally, a simple fix is to add the album to a playlist and revert the order of those tracks to that of the CD edition.

Two other major high marks on the LP are both produced by Antonoff, in case you thought I forgot about him at this point. “I Do This For You” and “FF” (an initialism for Fucking Forever) couldn’t be any more of a contrast, and yet, both of them have their place on this musical roulette wheel of a record. One’s got the funky, 90s-hip-hop-influenced percussion, the other some more sweat-dripping trip hop beats and a proper dream pop chorus only Antonoff could sell.

Troye Sivan has proven before how he and his team can craft excellent pop music, as on his first two albums, and She’s the Best is a compelling return to form front to back, even if the music isn’t nearly as hooky. I’m already seeing several comments on the Internet about how Sivan’s voice isn’t impressive enough or how this album is a ‘flop‘, to which I’d argue that the word ‘flop‘ is being used way too liberally in this example. Tastes will certainly differ, but I, for one, embrace this new alternative dance style from the openly gay Sivan. After all, who says queer musicians have to stick with generic pop? This is a welcome experiment for him, and I’d enjoy it if he continues down this wildly eclectic road in the future.

Leave a Reply